Warren was one of three rookie TEs who ranked in the top 10 at the position in receiving yards last season, along with Harold Fannin and Colston Loveland. Selected by the Colts at No. 14 overall, Warren paced the productive rookie trio with 76 catches and 817 receiving yards, while his 112 targets were the third-most among all NFL tight ends. He caught only four touchdown passes but added a rushing score on one of his six carries, showing some of the versatility that earned him Heisman hype at Penn State. Warren's production sank down the stretch last year, along with the rest of the Colts offense, as he had only 26 catches for 200 yards during the season-ending seven-game losing streak. After averaging 61.7 receiving yards in his first 10 NFL games, Warren averaged a mere 28.6 yards over his last seven appearances. He should nonetheless continue to see plenty of targets, especially with WR Michael Pittman (111 targets in 2025) now in Pittsburgh, but Warren may have to rely on quantity to mask a lack of quality with QB Daniel Jones coming back from a late-season Achilles tear.