Grupe is back with the Colts and set to compete with Spencer Shrader for the placekicker job, hoping to pick up where he left off last year when he made all 21 of his kicks (11 FGs, 10 PATs) in five games for Indianapolis. He even went 4-of-4 from 50-plus yards, including a 60-yarder, but Saints fans will tell a different story about Grupe's 2025 campaign and his career in general. The Saints released him in late November, following two-plus years in the kicker role, with Grupe having made just 79.8 percent of his career field-goal attempts at the time. The Colts will now have to weigh Grupe's strong work last December against his broader track record of mediocrity. In any case, the winner of a competition between Grupe and Shrader is unlikely to generate much fantasy interest, though there should at least be streaming appeal if the dome-based Colts field a solid team again.