Dynasty SF 10 man Breece For JSN

I think this is a bit of an overreaction to Breece's down year. I think hes worth more than JSN.

Hall is still an elite RB for me and JSN is good but not elite - think reading too much into the mess that was NY Jets this season - JSN had some big blow up games and while he finished as a top 10 WR he was 20th in ppg

man love both but gotta go JSN. hopefully the OC change doesnt affect him too much

Sorry OP this is our thread now

Rip my sweet prince Jonathan brooks

Didn’t mean to tag you there, was just a general statement

Bijan, Gibbs, Bucky, Saquon, Achane, Jeanty...

JSN unless I was a top contender and had minimal RB depth. JSN is legit as can be

I don’t think JSN is top 10 dynasty WR. Granted I haven’t ranked anyone yet, but…let’s just slow down a bit

Who is taking away traits - you said he exploded he has a solid season - had a 100 reception season very good - dodnt have a monster yardage or td season - much more impressed by a Rb with a 76 reception season on their resume

That’s the thing…injuries heal, but signing a suddenly surging Chubba to a 2-year extension…

Idk if spears is a fair comp

Spears has a million different injuries

Brooks has no injury history other than the ACL. I mean obviously it’s serious, but it’s hard to call him injury prone because of it

Had an amazing year at Texas before tearing it late season, and then for all we know something simply didn’t heal correctly which contributed to the reinjury

Point being…it’s not just the health. He has to have the opportunity, which means the guy in front of him has to warrant it

To bring it full circle, you could almost say something similar (though I think the gap is bigger) with Hall and Allen