Dynasty SF 10 man Breece For JSN

But could you fairly easily make an argument he should be RB6 or so, and ahead of or equal to Breece, sure.

Not saying he SHOULD be, but I can see an argument for it

@JamesMcGillEsq I was absolutely OUT on Bucky. In fact, there may be no player this side of Young I was more wrong about last year. Bucky is the reason I took 2nd instead of first in my redraft

I proudly and embarrassingly had Bucky as rookie rb3

Not sure how Breece has "a much higher ceiling". Frankly that seems counterintuitive. If anything a much higher floor

Rip my sweet prince Jonathan brooks

1

0 shares of Bucky in dynasty is pretty damn painful

Sorry OP this is our thread now

1

Right with both of you on Brooks. I’m trying to be optimistic…just almost nothing has gone right with him, nor does it look like it’s going to.

Yup

He’s gonna be Spears. Ridiculous talent, but health and opportunity just never line up for him

That’s the thing…injuries heal, but signing a suddenly surging Chubba to a 2-year extension…

Idk if spears is a fair comp

Spears has a million different injuries

Brooks has no injury history other than the ACL. I mean obviously it’s serious, but it’s hard to call him injury prone because of it

Had an amazing year at Texas before tearing it late season, and then for all we know something simply didn’t heal correctly which contributed to the reinjury

Point being…it’s not just the health. He has to have the opportunity, which means the guy in front of him has to warrant it

To bring it full circle, you could almost say something similar (though I think the gap is bigger) with Hall and Allen

@FearDaReaper23 @ChefHerbie @Steven @aweldon @A440 @garden91 curious how the moves in Seattle have affected your guys thoughts

I think its still solid depending what you need. Im personally taking JSN but still love breece and think he bounces back. Just depends what you need

@FearDaReaper23 @garden91 @aweldon damn I agree. I’m still absolutely going JSN. I thought a lot of people may have been scarred off because of the QB move but pleasantly surprised to see people are still high on him

@A440 very very fair, and basically completely agree. Both unquestionably great players at their respective positions, but just see the past 2 years as JSN trending the right way for utilization and efficiency, while Breece is trending the wrong way. He could absolutely course correct, but I think 2024 is closer to what the norm will be for Breece than what 2023 was

4.5YPA to 4.2. 58ypg to 54 95 targets to 76 targets