Dynasty SF 10 man Breece For JSN
Hall is an elite RB - JSN is not an elite WR
If you want to look at one season to say these 2 players are close by all means - these 2 aren’t close at all for me
lol
“Take away his good traits” is such a bad faith argument
He had like a 7 week stretch were 5 weeks he was WR15 or better
That’s not just a few blow up games, that’s a damn good emerging WR. Looking at who he was as a prospect and dismissing it as just a couple good fluke weeks is insanity
Who is taking away traits - you said he exploded he has a solid season - had a 100 reception season very good - dodnt have a monster yardage or td season - much more impressed by a Rb with a 76 reception season on their resume
Looking at one of the best Rb prospects of the last decade who we’ve seen produce and discounting him because of a down year in a horrific situation is what is insane to me
Where do you have JSN ranked in dynasty you doing copy pasta and have him at 7?
He’s also trending the wrong way for utilization and efficiency
He’s also in a dumpster fire organization where star WRs reportedly want out and they have no competent QB on their roster for next year
I don’t think JSN is top 10 dynasty WR. Granted I haven’t ranked anyone yet, but…let’s just slow down a bit
He looked pretty good for about an 8-game stretch
JSN unless I was a top contender and had minimal RB depth. JSN is legit as can be
Considering he entered the year as the presumed slot guy and 3rd option and grew to be the alpha, JSN deserves all the credit
In reality, he’s probably closer to 7 or 8 in my rankings
His only real barrier was (and still is) DK
and a god awful offensive line
Kinda disagree
His only real barrier is Geno imo
He and DK can coexist. A high level DK is probably a good thing for JSN imo. He absolutely feasts in the intermediate game. He’s got AmonRa 2.0 potential all over him, not the same player but similar utilization
Less physical, more talented version of AmonRa
This really probably comes down more to how someone feels about Breece, more so than JSN.
I’d pretty much agree with everything @ChefHerbie is saying. He’s saying everything I said, but much more succinctly