I have the #1 spot in this years rookie draft. Superflex league. I’m thinking MHJ over Caleb. What are your thoughts?

I’m firmly Caleb > MHJ in any 10+ team league

Based on team need it’s a toss up between the two

Trade for the 1.02 and take whoever is left over and reap the spoils you get on top of it

Either or works. My Bears are cursed so maybe good juju to go with MHJ

@LilArmee who are your QBs and WRs. Depends on your greater need

Caleb

Caleb over MHJ in 10+ man SF.

@Funderstruck QBs Murray, love, Wilson, fields, white. WRs Amon ra, G. Wilson, Hopkins, obj, rice, M Wilson, Austin, Menchie, Jameson Williams.

Honestly the need for each position is equal. You need a QB3 and WR3 haha

But still, I lean Caleb by a little.

@ESPN4Lyfe I forgot I also have Daniel Jones which isn’t great 😂

I say MH jr

@Flinders that’s what I’m thinking also. I just think Caleb is a douche 😂 I just don’t know if I could get past that and want to root for him.

Superflex, I think you get more drafting and trading Caleb than you would MHJ. Think the value is with Caleb

Yeah I’m not a fan of Caleb either, but his value is higher than MHJ’s in SF:

So just draft Caleb, and trade him if you don’t want him haha

Caleb. imo QB is king in SF and I will always go that route given the overall value and churn at the position. wouldnt fault anyone for going MHJ tho

I’d still go Caleb especially if that’s your only first round pick

@LilArmee I took MHJ over Caleb with the only 1.01 I had; it was a 12t SF, PPR, TEP dyno. I’m ranked #2 but still only have Herbs and TLaw at qb, so All consensus takes were to go Caleb. But I firmly avoid rookie QBs no matter the “pedigree”! I got the 1.01 by trading up to and selling the 1.03 in 2023… then got 2.01 and took LaPorta and 1.01 this yr for MHJ! 💰🤑💰

At 1.03 last yr, I would’ve been convinced to take Bryce over Stroud, even though I knew in my head Stroud would’ve been the better pick! …glad I didn’t listen to Everyone!!!

Bad idea. Take Caleb or trade back.

I’m gonna take MHJ. Mines a 10 team SF PPR league with 2 WRs and 2 flex. I have Josh Allen, Baker, Stafford, Daniel Jones, and Sam Howell. So I’m good at QB. I’m also stacked at WR but I just think Marv will be a much better player for me this year. 10 team leagues QBs are less important than 12 team leagues. In a 12 team league, I’d be 50/50 maybe. I just love MHJ and think Caleb has a 50/50 chance to be a bust with MHJ having a 10% chance to be a bust.