I have the #1 spot in this years rookie draft. Superflex league. I’m thinking MHJ over Caleb. What are your thoughts?

Superflex, I think you get more drafting and trading Caleb than you would MHJ. Think the value is with Caleb

Yeah I’m not a fan of Caleb either, but his value is higher than MHJ’s in SF:

So just draft Caleb, and trade him if you don’t want him haha

I’d still go Caleb especially if that’s your only first round pick

@LilArmee I took MHJ over Caleb with the only 1.01 I had; it was a 12t SF, PPR, TEP dyno. I’m ranked #2 but still only have Herbs and TLaw at qb, so All consensus takes were to go Caleb. But I firmly avoid rookie QBs no matter the “pedigree”! I got the 1.01 by trading up to and selling the 1.03 in 2023… then got 2.01 and took LaPorta and 1.01 this yr for MHJ! 💰🤑💰

At 1.03 last yr, I would’ve been convinced to take Bryce over Stroud, even though I knew in my head Stroud would’ve been the better pick! …glad I didn’t listen to Everyone!!!

Bad idea. Take Caleb or trade back.

I’m gonna take MHJ. Mines a 10 team SF PPR league with 2 WRs and 2 flex. I have Josh Allen, Baker, Stafford, Daniel Jones, and Sam Howell. So I’m good at QB. I’m also stacked at WR but I just think Marv will be a much better player for me this year. 10 team leagues QBs are less important than 12 team leagues. In a 12 team league, I’d be 50/50 maybe. I just love MHJ and think Caleb has a 50/50 chance to be a bust with MHJ having a 10% chance to be a bust.

MHJ

I rlly don’t think people realize. He’s the most definite WR prospect since like Julio Jones. You gotta take the chance on him no matter ehat

top 2