10 Team SF. Start 9. Already have Burrow and Richardson at QB. GIVE: Darnold + McCarthy GET: Herbert
I’d rather have the depth with having Richardson
I like Herbert a lot but I'm not giving up two quarterbacks for him unless both are downgrades and I'm not sure McCarthy is.
I would rather trade Arich and McCarthy for Herbert if I could, Arich is a bust, just some people can't either admit it or I guess maybe they can't see it, I'm not a Darnold fan but he has shown he is capable of starting in the NFL, McCarthy hasn't even taken a snap and I have concerns about him, I like starting Burrow and Herbert and I'm comfortable with Darnold as my number 3
Herbert easily
Give me Herbert, you can flip Herbert for way more than the combo of Darnold and McCarthy
I’d lean towards keeping the two. Mainly because I think both have depressed values for relatively small reasons. Ultimately, I think the two will be worth more than the one
