Kyler or Caleb Williams? 10 team, Dynasty, SF

Caleb. I think he offers a higher ceiling

caleb

Caleb

I’m currently wondering where the Kyler fan club is at so far this offseason. He seems to get an annual groundswell that pushes him well above middling (which is typically his output). I’d go with Caleb only because I think he has no where to go but up. How far remains to be seen. He’s definitely good at not making costly mistakes, and that alone will keep him in a starting role for at least a decade.

Caleb

@cvgibbs @A440 @KingYeti @aweldon @vanderzielky @Isaaaaaaac Would something need to be added to the williams side? caleb owner also has rome... would be ideal to get the stack but what plus kyler equals caleb and rome

as of right now they are very close to me but it is hard for me to say what would need to be added because there a lot of variables with Caleb value - HC/OC system, OL and WR additions so it can only go up. as far as getting the stack, you are gonna need to add probably a 1st on top of Kyler. if just getting Caleb, maybe try a 3rd on top as an initial offer because I see Caleb value going up more over offseason than Kyler overall

I’d go Caleb for sure, but honestly both feel like buys rn