Dynasty Question: on KTC ans other sites there’s a pretty significant gap in perceived value between Gibbs and Achane. With the amount of mouths to feed in Detroit, do you think the production difference is going to support that gap or do u think Achane is a good “tier down” trade target for Gibbs?

🕒 Latest

I think a lot of the gap is people concerned about achane being injury prone. Tbh both of them have competing backs but overall I’d still take Gibbs between the 2. Both have great upside in the pass game, just more perceived risk for achane but that’s just my take. I can see them putting up similar really good numbers this year

ChefHerbie 20 days ago

Gibbs is well clear of Achane

Townies1 20 days ago

^ I agree

aweldon 20 days ago

I mean ok tier down but depends what you are getting back. the gap is mostly imo around the amount of touches they can handle and where they are in the pecking order of their backfields. Gibbs is viewed as the 1A and I think shown he can handle a 20+ touch workload whereas Achane might still be the 1B and the concerns around his durability

cgorick 20 days ago

Gibbs by a good bit.

EdsBackpack 20 days ago

It's also because gibbs has 1st round draft capital. Very big difference in terms of contract and longevity