Hall of Fame has revealed its semifinalists for the Class of 2025. Eli Manning is on the list which begs the question - should Eli Manning be in the HOF? 🤔
He doesn't belong in same category as Montana,Marino,Peyton etc
He was not one of the greatest qbs of all time .Not close
Looking at Joe Namath stats he wasn't either
No, but he will
Beat the Patriots in the SB twice. He'd have my vote
He beat the GOAT twice - let him in idc about the stats
If we consider team wins a meaningful stat for individual players, then yes
But I certainly wouldn’t vote for Nick Foles to get into the HOf
He beat Tom Brady
Yessir
he should be in there
Ok but Joe Flacco has to also then
Yo now I’ve got something that’s definitely gon hit 💯hit me up
Not before James Harrison
Is he a HOF qb no. Can you tell the story of the NFLs history without him also no. So that gets him in.
Y not
Not even a question ofc yes
222 no is crazy
Beating Brady 2wice for the SB win is an automatic walk in.
Personally winning 2 SBs and 2 SB MVPS warrants it even if he was pretty much average his entire career. If Joe Namath is in so should Eli.
But remember Eli wasn’t elite.
He has a historic career regardless of stats so that is deserving of HOF
Yes he is a better QB than Brady and he proved it twice
Two time Super Bowl MVP. Led 2 game winning drives in the Super Bowl. Beat the best team ever.