Would you guys trade Saquon to receive Jamhyr Gibbs straight up in dynasty or would the Saquon side need to offer more?

Saquon side needs to add more due to age difference

I would not be looking to tier down from Gibbs to a much older Saquon coming off a career season. I can't see that there is something that is both worthwhile to the Gibbs owner, and palatable to the Saquon owner. But sure, give it a go.

I’d definitely do it if they’ll take it. I doubt they will though. Would likely need to add

This is hard because Saquon is the only RB. Gibbs will be in a timeshare. I tend to think straight up is fine but giving up more than Saquon is just not smart

I’d need like pick 1.06-1.07 on top of Saquon to get rid of Gibbs

Must add more on top of Saquon to reach a Gibbs acquisition

yeah Gibbs all day

The only way I'm giving up Gibbs to get Saquon is if I'm completely rebuilding and could get a solid asset on top and then flip Saquon to a contender.

Win now Saquon, rebuild Gibbs

Well guys I traded Saquon away for Gibbs straight up! For context, I came in second place last season and the Gibbs owner came in first, so I just traded Saquon to the defending champion for Gibbs