12 team sf .5 Pennix + ? = kyler?? Player or picks I got this dude willing to move kyler but he wants an add on..

LonghornsATW2025 10 months ago

Hot take Penix qb1 one next year (not biased)

appreciate it!!

Kyler finished 10th overall fantasy QB last year, he was injured the year before but consistently finished as a top 5 QB on a weekly basis the year before that, I wouldn't toss him just yet, and I, personally would take him over Penix easy, I just haven't seen enough of Penix in the NFL to know what he is yet, but I was high on him coming out of college and still expect him to be a NFL quarterback for a long time, i do agree that I wouldn't add a lot to Penix for him, but I think he is a safer play with just as much if not more upside as Penix, plus he has a year with MHJ now, who's expectations as a rookie were unreasonable, I'm obviously the minority, but I would trade for him

A440 10 months ago

Really have no idea why there’s always a weird groundswell for Kyler. He’s crazy inconsistent (which is the last thing I want for my QB). While he’s finished in the back half of the top 10 a few times (PPG), that doesn’t actually mean anything, it’s just a ranking with no value. The only year he was a true difference maker was 2021. I would not add anything to that trade. Personally, I’d rather have Penix (then again, I was very high on him in the draft). But at best, it’s an even swap to me.