Devonta Smith or Brian Thomas Jr?

Give me BTJ just for upside alone.

Yea it’s the upside for me. Smitty seems kinda capped

Upside???? You see top 10 in the range of outcomes for BTJ? That’s crazy to me

Jj wasn't top wr drafted Un his year

Don’t get suckered into the rookie fever @Adam11534 BTJ is good but I wouldn’t say he’s special and in an offense that will continue to spread the ball around

But I'm not gonna critisize

His opinion

Gotcha

On team or as in a top 10 WR @ESPN4Lyfe ?

Yeah won’t argue against that at all

Smith

This is for dynasty btw. I feel like if he’s WR1 on the jaguars then he will indeed shine in a couple years; this is the piece tlaw needs

But smith has a top 10 season so didn’t understand the upside point

Smitty. Obviously

I don’t think smith will put up another top 10 season though

That’s fair

@Steven appreciate the input

BTJ is like the wr 5 in rookie drafts rn lmao

DEVONTA

Smith everyday of the week

Smitty not close.

I mean the value lies with Smith atm. He’s a sure thing and rookies are not. if you are trading smith for BTJ, you need to sweeten the pot. That being said, I WANT BTJ for 2 reasons and you need to believe them both for him to be better than smith. 1) I still believe in TLaw emerging into a super star and reestablishing his 1st overall draft capital. 2) I believe that BTJ can improve routes and is a more multidimensional WR than displayed at LSU.

btj could get to ths level but not yet... we dont even know (though he should) if he will take the X