J brooks or R White?

White should be the correct answer no matter what

@zakainsworth they’re pretty close to even for me. I’ll go Brooks if rebuilding, Rachaad if you want the best chance to compete in 2024

I have white and recieved the offer. 1qb 12 teamer I have QB A-rich Caleb Bryce young RB Bijan R White zeke charbonet k miller and Chuba Hubbard WR MHJ Nico Collins D London JSN Pickens TE laporta Kincaid bowers Start 8

and i usually stay away from 1 for 1 trades

I rank them close to each other, but couldn’t pull the trigger without consulting the community

White

I’m going Brooks EASILY on this one personally, this is dynasty and I get White had a big FANTASY year. But he was bottom 5 in every important advanced rushing statistic. His production this past season was solely contingent on his absurd usage which imo you shouldn’t count on for the long term.

Bottom 5 in yards after contact per attempt, bottom 5 in missed tackles forced per attempt, bottom 5 in rushing yards over expectation and much more. He’s honestly never been a good between the tackles runner even when coming out of college. They already stated they were getting more people involved as well, I know there’s always empty offseason reports but White being atrociously inefficient while being given all the opportunity makes me feel as though this report has some substance to it.

If you are rebuilding then go Brooks but if any chance you can contend then I’ll go White

Brooksy