Dynasty 12 PPR A. Josh Jacobs and 2027 1st Or B. James Cook

James cook is 2 years younger but in the life of a RB that’s a long time. Pass catching is also a strength for Cook over Jacobs. Jacobs has better rushing ability imo but fell off last year. Zamir white had no problem when he took over in that raider offense

ik jones was hurt often but he was still a very good back

He’s also 29

I’m leaning cook side. I have Jacobs and could see it being a fun year with him but it’s tough either way for me

and not for nothing but i dont agree with a lot of @ThomasOBrien 's takes 😂

Appreciate the input from both of you, at the end of the day it’s just fantasy football and we are allowed to disagree lol

Yeah everyone is allowed to have an opinion lol

I don’t think jacobs our scores cook anymore in his career. 2027 is a far ways away id take took

as long as jacobs is a packer i think jacobs will outscore cook

cook is more of a RB12-15 i can see jacobs finishing inside the top ten

also i forgot to mention too the packers have reported they are gonna try to get jacobs more involved in the passing game

You could be right. Do any of us really know? lol

take that for what its worth but interesting to note

@AngryD I don't think there's a definite argument for either side on this one. Jacobs 2 years ago was the rushing leader, but last year was not great at all. I think he can thrive in GB. Likewise, I think Cook will still be a beast for the Bills. Davis will probably take goal line and some touches, but Cook's role was limited and he was still RB12 last year. I would probably go with A, just because I love having picks and I don't think the difference in value is all that much between the two. Could see an argument for both sides though

That’s your opinion lol for people who thinks jacobs isn’t great anymore they would disagree

if jacobs wasnt great anymore i once again question why the packers signed him to a 4 year deal 😂

and moved on from a franchise rb theyve had for a while

I'd take Jacobd over Cook str8 up

A by a lot

Like a lot a lot lol

Jacobs > Cook straight up, adding a first is wild

@Townies1 Jacobs was so bad last year and you saying you would take Jacobs over a top 12 running back in James Cook is unbelievable dumb and no questions you knowing anything about football!

@Billsarethebest Jacobs literally had a higher PPG than cook last year lmao